COVID-19 Worsening Mental Health Of 59% Of Healthcare Industry Workers: KPMG Survey

COVID-19 Worsening Mental Health Of 59% Of Healthcare Industry Workers: KPMG Survey
Image source: Google

Employees point to improved quality of work, collaboration, stronger ties to company and co-workers

NEW YORK: Nearly three out of five healthcare workers (59%) say COVID-19 has worsened their mental health, representing an eight percentage point gap when compared with other industries (51%), a pulse survey of 1,000 workers by KPMG LLP, the U.S. audit, tax and advisory firm, found.

Despite the stresses in healthcare, the survey also found greater connections, collaboration and higher quality of their work among 194 workers surveyed from that sector in April.

"COVID-19 is a career defining event for many healthcare professionals, given the severity of the condition, the necessary protocols to prevent coronavirus from spreading, and that many have families at home that are dealing with the effects of social distancing," said Ashraf Shehata, national sector leader for healthcare & life sciences at KPMG LLP, the U.S. audit, tax and advisory firm.  

The survey also found:

  • 59% of healthcare workers report their mental health has worsened.
  • Two thirds of healthcare workers say their level of engagement with their supervisor/team (66%) and co-worker relationships have improved (66%).
  • While 70% of healthcare workers report their quality of work has improved, only 56% say their level of productivity has improved.
  • Over half (57%) of healthcare workers say their level of engagement with company culture has improved.
  • Half (54%) of healthcare workers say their work/life balance has improved.
  • Three fourths (76%) of healthcare workers report their team is collaborating better.

Compared with the national averages in the survey, healthcare workers are significantly more likely to not be concerned about reduced pay (37% vs 52%), losing their job (43% vs 56%), technology replacing their job (56% vs 71%), and the future of their industry (44% vs 62%). "Healthcare workers tend to band together when times are difficult and deliver upon the task at hand, which is providing the highest quality care to the best of their abilities," Shehata said. "The best healthcare organizations pride themselves on creating a great place to work, because they realize that an appreciated worker is valuable to providing the best patient experience."

Which of the following has improved or worsened due to the 
impact of COVID-19?

 

 -My mental health

     
       
 

Healthcare 
(n=194)

TOTAL 
(N=1000)

Industry average without 
healthcare (n=806)

Has significantly worsened

11%

11%

11%

Has somewhat worsened

47%

42%

41%

Has somewhat improved

31%

33%

33%

Has significantly improved

10%

14%

15%

       

NET : Improved

41%

47%

49%

       

NET : Worsened

59%

53%

51%

*figures rounded

About the survey

KPMG conducted a pulse survey of 1,000 workers, which included 19 in the U.S. in April 2020 to gauge how employees were adjusting to COVID-19 work-from-home orders. The survey of healthcare workers did not make the distinction between clinical and support staff. The sample included a diverse mix of full-time and part-time workers from a variety of industries, company sizes and management levels. To see the full results, visit https://advisory.kpmg.us/articles/2020/covid-american-worker.html.